From the Wires
Former Chairman and CEO Kaleil Isaza Tuzman Sends Letter to KIT digital Board of Directors
Urges Company to Discuss Acquisition Offer and Conduct Open and Transparent Sale Process
By: PR Newswire
Nov. 23, 2012 06:59 AM
NEW YORK, Nov. 23, 2012 /PRNewswire/ --
Board of Directors
Attention: Bill Russell, Chairman
Dear KIT digital Board of Directors,
KIT digital, Inc.'s ("KITD" or the "Company") November 21, 2012 8-K (the "8-K") effectively blamed prior management for the Company's delayed filing of third quarter results and the Company's intent to restate its financial statements for the 2009-2011 period, among other issues. The Company's attempt to attribute its current problems to prior management is spurious.
As one of KITD's largest shareholders and the Company's former chairman and CEO, I have kept my opinions on the Company's trajectory confidential since my departure in April 2012, in deference to the efforts being expended by current management and to avoid unnecessary discord. However, I can no longer silently abide the Company's attempt to scapegoat previous management or tolerate the recent record of deficient management and poor business execution. KITD shareholders deserve to be leveled with on what has occurred at the Company to date, and shown a path forward to success and enhancement of share value, as we have set forth below.
First, some clarifications concerning some implications contained in the Company's recent 8-K. During my tenure at the Company, all revenue recognition decisions were made in consultation with and approved by the Company's independent accounting firm, and approved by your audit committee. We have no reason to believe any of those decisions were improper. Since my departure, it is possible that your new audit committee members have elected, in consultation with the firm's outside auditors, to apply different revenue recognition policies. That is not prior management's responsibility, and a change in revenue recognition policies and application may reflect your recently insinuated decision to further separate the "software" and "services" lines of the Company's business. As shareholders, we cannot yet opine on the merit of your decision, since your 8-K lacked details on the matter.
Similarly, the 8K's vague reference to a lack of disclosure concerning certain undisclosed "related party transactions" is misleading and inappropriate. During my tenure with KITD, all related party transactions were vetted by KITD's outside counsel and relevant disclosures in KITD financial statements were reviewed and approved by the Company's independent accounting firm. For instance, as you know, my affiliate investment companies, KIT Media and KIT Capital, supported the Company by investing on four different occasions between 2008 and 2011 in public share issuances alongside other public shareholders. These transactions were "related party transactions" in nature and were disclosed in great detail in press releases and Company financial statements at the time. The transactions were very positive for the Company (and included two successfully completed financings during the depth of the 2008-2009 financial crisis) and were broadly lauded by KITD's shareholder base at the time as demonstrating management's "skin in the game." In addition, stock options and restricted stock grants over time to me or KIT Capital for services rendered were also described in detail in the Company's public filings. Accordingly, these transactions were all appropriately disclosed and benefited the Company and its shareholders—and, in fact, neither myself nor KIT Capital has ever exercised or sold any of these stock grants or options, nor have I received a single dollar or share in severance.
By comparison, you granted former CEO Barak Bar-Cohen a $250,000 "success bonus" for an extremely dilutive, death-spiral financing concluded after my departure and JEC Capital (the New York hedge fund which currently controls the Company and for which current KITD CEO Peter Heiland serves as Managing Director) recently lent $2.5 million to the Company without a concomitant press release—and the mention of this related party transaction received only cursory mention in an indirectly related SEC filing.
Given the 8-K's emphasis on the dire current liquidity situation of the Company, it appears to us that you, in conjunction with the Company's senior creditors, may be conspiring to artificially decrease the Company's stock price so as to acquire the Company at a fire sale price that is unfair to shareholders. Indeed, the 8-K's disclosure regarding covenant breaches of current lender agreements could be interpreted as a lead-in to a pre-arranged, sweetheart deal with the Company's lenders.
Previous management presided over a period between December 2007 and March 2012 during which monthly revenues expanded over 20x, operating results went from huge losses to small gains, and the Company's shares appreciated from $2.90 to over $9.00. Despite your attempt to blame past management for your current results, those close to the Company report that current management has shown disregard for the underlying business—including key clients, employees and vendors. Most startlingly, you seem to have presided over the Company burning more cash from operations in the seven months since I left than the Company had burned from operations in the prior two fiscal years.
Adding to KITD's problems, the Company's current management has:
Ignoring these poor managerial decisions, the Company instead seeks to scapegoat prior management in describing its current condition. It is time to redress this situation.
I originally resigned from my post as CEO of KITD in March 2012 (and subsequently resigned from his role as Chairman in April, 2012) because I had come to irreconcilable differences with the Board at the time concerning strategic decisions and the future of the Company. As a major shareholder, I ultimately felt I could make a greater positive impact on the Company's development from the outside than from within, especially considering that the Board formed a Special Strategic Committee (the "Special Committee") in January 2012 which had effectively taken control of all CEO-level decisions.
By way of background, in December 2011, my core management team had recommended to the Board that the Company complete a major restructuring and consolidation of operations (a plan that you finally began to implement about two months ago). We also recommended to the Board at such time that the Company pursue two competing strategic transactions, each with the potential to be a homerun for shareholders (one a private equity buy-out and the other a merger-of-equals). Instead, the Board rejected management's suggested approach and formed the Special Committee with a broad mandate to oversee "any and all strategic decisions" at the Company. The Special Committee was comprised of two board members—Wayne R. Walker and Santo Politi—and immediately shut down or irreparably delayed the discussions with the strategic transaction counterparties. KITD's management-by-special-committee was predictably dysfunctional. After months of wrestling with the Special Committee to no avail, myself and several members of the core management team eventually resigned.
In connection with my resignation I issued a letter—which was publicly filed by the Company as an 8-K at the time—stating that I intended to independently consider strategic alternatives for the Company. After my resignation, a bidding group (led by a large private equity firm which I had introduced to the Company), endeavored to obtain approval from the Special Committee to share information with me so that I could participate in connection with a potential offer for KITD. Unfortunately, the Special Committee refused this request, to the detriment of all shareholders.
Since that time, KIT Capital and other prospective bidders have been repeatedly delayed or stonewalled in our continued efforts to create shareholder value, while the indecision and delay of new management and board continues to result in value destruction. For example, although KITD's current management and board finally adopted the staff reduction and office consolidation plan prior management first put forward almost a year ago, the delay has caused KITD to effectively run out of money and may put the Company into the pockets of its lenders.
KITD must right its ship. From an operational perspective, KITD management must immediately:
We do not believe that current management is capable of the actions listed in this letter. As a result, we are prepared to lead a bidding group to buy the Company at a reasonable and substantial cash premium to the current traded price of the Company's common stock. Since May 2012, we have repeatedly requested that the board engage with us and certain other private equity firms regarding a strategic transaction for the Company. In light of KITD's mismanagement and the Company's current circumstances, the Board can no longer afford to ignore these overtures.
Based on our analysis of publicly available information, and subject to due diligence and the execution of a mutually acceptable definitive agreement, we are prepared to lead a bidding group to buy the Company at $3.75 per share in cash, which represents an 81% premium to the closing price of KITD common stock on Wednesday, November 21, 2012 (and an approximately 750% premium to the reported after-market trading price of KITD common stock on that date). We have reviewed this transaction with two large private equity groups who are interested in participating with us, and believe we have the backing of the Company's prior and current executives, salespeople and senior engineers who would be key to execute on our plan to right the KITD ship. We believe we can finalize financing and business terms with respect to this acquisition very quickly if the Board responds forthwith.
For the benefit of all the shareholders, we ask that you to cease and desist from defamatory and inaccurate descriptions of KITD's prior management and immediately engage in an open dialogue with us on this offer.
Kaleil Isaza Tuzman
On behalf of:
Contact: Jonathan Cutler
SOURCE Kaleil Isaza Tuzman
Latest AJAXWorld RIA Stories
Subscribe to the World's Most Powerful Newsletters
Subscribe to Our Rss Feeds & Get Your SYS-CON News Live!
SYS-CON Featured Whitepapers
Most Read This Week